Why dieting does not usually work – insights from a scientists on weight set point and how we need to focus on healthy lifestyle rather than diets


In the following TED talk, neuroscientist Sandra Aamodt talks about how our brains manage our bodies, as she explores the science behind why dieting does not work, but can do more harm than good. She suggests ideas for how to live a less diet-obsessed life, intuitively.

In her talk Sandra Aamodt talks about Set Point Theory.

Set Point Theory is the idea that your body has an innate weight range that it tries to maintain. And everyone's set point is unique to them. It’s just one of several theories.

According to Set Point Theory, if you’re losing weight, your metabolism slows down, and you feel more hungry to help make sure you stay within your range.

On the other hand, if you overeat, a feedback mechanism ups your metabolism, and your hunger signals slow down, helping to keep you from gaining weight as easily.

But weight management is very complicated, and there are many aspects of body weight regulation that scientists don’t yet understand. Overall, it seems easier for most people to gain weight in the long term, rather than lose it. For that reason, rates of obesity are increasing with each new generation.

Some environments and food cultures likely promote weight gain.

If Set Point Theory is correct, these environmental influences may be overriding your set point.

Set Point Theory may help explain why most people find it very tricky to lose weight and why 80% of people regain lost weight within 2–5 years. 

If you’re trying to lose weight and finding it challenging, this theory may be of interest or a comfort and help show how many factors are at play when it comes to weight loss. 

Healthy layered salad in a jar with fresh vegetables, grains, and seeds — representing balanced, sustainable nutrition for long-term weight management.

Weight Loss vs Weight Management: What’s the Difference?

Person jogging along a forest path, symbolizing healthy lifestyle and sustainable weight management in Galway.

Weight Loss Clinic Galway | Evidence-Based Weight Management with a CORU Dietitian

Container of protein powder with a scoop, illustrating high-protein nutrition for maintaining and building muscle, as advised by a CORU registered Galway dietitian.

Preventing and Reversing Muscle Loss with Nutrition – Advice from a Galway Dietitian

3D illustration of the human digestive system showing intestines and gut structure, used for IBS and gut health guidance by a CORU-registered dietitian.

Frequently Asked Questions about IBS and Gut Health

Bowl of blueberries, blackberries, raspberries, and grapes, illustrating a brain-healthy, antioxidant-rich snack to support memory and cognitive function.

Brain Health Checklist


© 2025 Galway Nutrition & Therapy Clinic Ireland is powered by WebHero | Terms & Conditions | Privacy Policy

Sign up for our free latest recipes, articles and nutrition news.